A journalist asked this Syrian refugee girl to smile. What a huge ask. What an impossible ask. How fucking insensitive.
What we do to children is often unbearable. Not only do we bomb their communities, kill their relatives, their parents, brothers and sisters, but we ask them to smile.
I think I know why he asked her. He wanted her to stand for something more than just a little girl with a broken heart; maybe something to do with resilience, with the will to carry on. Maybe he wanted his photo to signify something more than just a young girl with a grief laden face. I don’t know.
I must say I sometimes agree with the idea that photographers can “steal our souls”. I doubt he could actually steal her soul, but he added to her burden. He asked her to smile and she, wanting to please, accommodated him. Damn him or her. Damn them.
She breaks my heart.